top of page
Search

Hyperparathyroidism, Vitamin D and Magnesium

Writer: Sallie PowellSallie Powell

Updated: Jun 18, 2024

We all know that a huge percentage of the population has issues with low vitamin D. A lot of people know that some doctors have been telling patients with hypercalcemia, that they shouldn't take vitamin D at all because it will increase calcium. That's not strictly true. We don't recommend large doses of vitamin D with hypercalcemia. In fact, we don't recommend very large doses of vitamin D for anyone. We know the vitamin D groups will disagree, and that they recommend larger doses based on body weight.


  • How many doctors tell patients that vitamin D is fat soluble. Do they even know?

  • How many doctors know that magnesium is essential in the metabolism of vitamin D, and that taking large doses of vitamin D can induce severe depletion of Magnesium? Adequate magnesium supplementation should be considered as an important aspect of vitamin D therapy.

  • How many doctors consider that calcium might be within the normal range in the presence of elevated PTH due to insufficient magnesium?

People with hypothyroidism, diabetes, fibromyalgia, malabsorption, will also very likely have lower magnesium.


Many of us know that the serum blood test for magnesium only represents about 1% of magnesium stored in the body. That doesn't necessarily mean its a pointless blood test, far from it. Not only is it a really cheap blood test for the NHS, but low in the range (below 0.82) is reported to increase the risk of ischemic strokes by over 60%. We see many who do get magnesium tested who are told by doctors that their level is fine even if its marginally above 0.7 (0.7-1.00) which isn't true, but how many doctors actually know how to interpret population reference ranges? Of course, we would like to see the RBC magnesium test available and 24 hour urinary magnesium excretion test; https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/medicine-and-dentistry/magnesium-excretion#:~:text=The%20fractional%20urinary%20excretion%20of,drop%20in%20plasma%20magnesium%20concentration. Those taking PPIs are at risk of hypomagnesemia (and of course it reduces calcium also).

'Proton pump inhibitors (PPIs) are commonly used in clinical practice for the prevention and treatment of peptic ulcer, gastritis, esophagitis and gastroesophageal reflux. Hypomagnesemia has recently been recognized as a side effect of PPIs. Low magnesium levels may cause symptoms from several systems, some of which being potentially serious, such as tetany, seizures and arrhythmias. It seems that PPIs affect the gastrointestinal absorption of magnesium. Clinicians should be vigilant in order to timely consider and prevent or reverse hypomagnesemia in patients who take PPIs, especially if they are prone to this electrolyte disorder.' https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3782221/#:~:text=Hypomagnesemia%20has%20recently%20been%20recognized,the%20gastrointestinal%20absorption%20of%20magnesium.


Low levels of magnesium stimulate parathyroid hormone secretion, as do low levels of vitamin D and calcium. Going into parathyroid surgery with low levels of magnesium can induce a paradoxical block of PTH. We have seen several such cases, where patients are admitted back into A&E soon after being discharged from surgery, where doctors have been left baffled by hypocalcemia and low PTH. Administering IV magnesium, restores equilibrium. Whilst our members are educated about the necessity of magnesium, we are concerned for patients who haven't found us. We would appreciate doctors becoming more aware about magnesium and testing it as routine when testing calcium, PTH, and vitamin D. Information studies about magnesium can be found in abundance online. Please find some time to educate yourselves about the benefits and importance of magnesium. Here are a few examples; 'Association between hypomagnesemia and severity of primary hyperparathyroidism: a retrospective study': https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34416890/ 'Serum Magnesium Measurements After Parathyroidectomy for Primary Hyperparathyroidism: Should It be Routine?' https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00268-020-05425-1#:~:text=Serum%20magnesium%20decreased%20significantly%20following,%2Doperative%2C%20mostly%20mild%20hypomagnesaemia. Magnesium and the parathyroid: 'The serum levels of parathyroid hormone and magnesium depend on each other in a complex manner' : https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12105390/


'A patient with Crohn's disease receiving vitamin D and calcium had normal serum calcium levels when serum magnesium was low. Hypercalcaemia was precipitated when supplemental magnesium was given. The reason why serum calcium was initially normal is probably related to the effect of magnesium deficiency in reducing serum calcium level. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3991404/#:~:text=Hypercalcaemia%20was%20precipitated%20when%20supplemental,in%20reducing%20serum%20calcium%20level.


'Optimal magnesium status is required for optimal vitamin D status. Both magnesium and vitamin D are important to the immune system independently. Together, they may be beneficial in COVID-19 infection because magnesium is necessary to activate vitamin D.'

'The adequate balance of magnesium and vitamin D is essential for maintaining the physiologic functions of various organs. Vitamin D helps regulate calcium and phosphate balance to maintain healthy bone functions.Skeletal muscles, heart, teeth, bones, and many other organs require magnesium to sustain their physiologic functions. Furthermore, magnesium is needed to activate vitamin D. Abnormal levels in either of these nutrients can lead to serious organ dysfunctions.' https://www.degruyter.com/document/doi/10.7556/jaoa.2018.037/html

It is important to know that magnesium shouldn't be taken at the same time as calcium, zinc or levothyroxine, but should be separated by 3-4 hours.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

コメント


Books published by Sallie Powell
A Normal Christmas - Lighthearted HyperPARAthyroid adaptation of 'A Christmas Carol'

Written in 2020 after seeing many operations cancelled due to the pandemic. The aim was to try to get across a very serious message to clinicians, using a well known Christmas story with an important lesson to learn, to raise awareness of surgery benefits for patients with normocalcemic primary hyperparathyroidism, a very common endocrine disease which is sadly still under recognised and under treated in the UK. The main character in A Normal Christmas, is a very kind parathyroid surgeon about to experience a very different Christmas Eve after a very different 2020.


There are of course, three Ghosts of Christmas Past, Present and Future, very unlike those in other adaptations of A Christmas Carol, as well as a lovely dog named Bella (RIP my darling girl). A fictional story based very loosely on true stories. I've included medical studies in Chapter Six to show how normocalcemic PHPT isn't fictional at all, but has been written about since 1969.

If your clinician doesn't believe in Normocalcemic Primary Hyperparathyroidism, maybe buy them a copy of this book for Christmas.

 

'A Normal Christmas' has a happy ending. That's all hyperparathyroid patients are looking for, our happy ending. 
 

True case stories are included at the end of the book. Available from Amazon on paperback or Kindle (£5.99/£3.99) 
 

A normal Christmas.png
It's Not All About the Levels - Normocalcaemic Primary HyperPARAthyroidism

The astonishing medical mystery surrounding Normocalcaemic Primary Hyperparathyroidism (NCPHPT) is that many clinicians claim it is controversial, or it doesn’t exist and/or doesn’t need surgery (parathyroidectomy -the only cure) which is offered to hypercalcaemic PHPT patients. The reason they cite is 'Normocalcaemic PHPT can’t cause symptoms.’ which is nonsense (known as Medical Gaslighting).  NCPHPT patients are often refused PTH blood tests, scans and referrals to surgeons, by doctors, based on calcium levels alone. Those doctors are mistaken. Whether basing their beliefs on NICE guidelines (NG132) published 23 May 2019, or their own personal misguided understanding of NCPHPT, most doctors are relaying misinformation to patients, putting them at risk of serious harm, including cardiac events including sudden cardiac death, (linked to elevated PTH). If patients can learn about Primary Hyperparathyroidism, why can’t clinicians? I've included 60 case stories including my own and many reasons for serum calcium levels being reduced, which does not exclude Primary Hyperparathyroidism. Reasons which have escaped clinicians until now. I hope if they read this book, they will say to themselves, oh crikey, how did we not know that?...The time to change is NOW.

 

It's Not All About the Levels: Normocalcaemic Primary HyperPARAthyroidism (NCPHPT): Amazon.co.uk: Powell, Sallie: 9798357345424: Books

Available only on paperback currently at Amazon, but hoping to be available on Kindle by in 2025. (delayed by an unfortunate diagnosis of BC - SJP)

Its not all about the levels.png

One Hundred Letters

Over one hundred letters were sent by our group members on 15th March 2021, to Sir Simon Stevens, CEO of NHS England. The heartfelt letters described years of misdiagnosis, the pointless and cruel 'Watch and Wait' regime upheld by many endocrinologists, and the battle many of us face to be heard by doctors who seem determined to find any other reason for our symptoms, rather than primary hyperparathyroidism. The only reason we can see for this barbaric practice, is ignorance, but how can so many clinicians still be completely ignorant about this disease, when patients can learn the complexities of PHPT (because they are left with no choice, in order to educate their doctors). 

 

We wrote asking them to take our health seriously and to help us to get a timely diagnosis of hyperparathyroidism and surgery.  We asked them to instigate a review of the disappointing NICE guidelines NG132. We also sent letters to Professor Amanda Howe, at RCGP, and I sent copies to the CEO s of Wales and Scotland, and the Minsters for Health in Ireland and Northern Ireland.  Robin Swann sent a very gracious response. Wales sent a very quick response saying there isn't a problem with diagnosis and how easy it is... Which is the opposite of feedback from members in Wales.

NHS England and RCGP responses, one from a representative at RCGP, and two from Jan, a case officer for NHS England (one to London and one to Australia) were dismissive, disinterested and frankly an insult, considering the nature of the letters, and the effort put into writing them (in vain) hoping someone at the top of the NHS might give a damn about the poor treatment and neglect of patients.  I felt the letters deserved to be read, so I published them. One Hundred Letters is available on kindle or paperback at Amazon: 

One Hundred Letters by Sallie Powell and members of Hyperparathyroid UK Action4Change, is available on kindle or paperback from Amazon. Follow the link below or scan the code. https://www.amazon.co.uk/One-Hundred-Letters-Hyperparathyroidism-professionals/dp/B094T5SJ6S/ref=tmm_pap_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&qid=&sr=

 

If you read these letters, a review would be very much appreciated.  Thank you.

qrcode_www.amazon.co.uk.png
bottom of page